Andiswa Mengo is a South African court secretary who has become the central figure in a high-profile sexual harassment case involving Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge. Her allegations have led to a Judicial Conduct Tribunal, which is examining claims of misconduct and abuse of power within the South African judiciary.
In January 2023, Mengo filed a formal complaint against Judge President Mbenenge, accusing him of sexual harassment. She alleges that between June 2021 and November 2022, Mbenenge engaged in inappropriate in-person and electronic interactions with her, including sending sexually explicit WhatsApp messages and making unwanted advances. Mengo contends that these interactions were unwelcome and that she felt compelled to engage due to the power dynamics at play.
Mengo’s testimony has been consistent, asserting that she did not reciprocate Mbenenge’s advances and that his behavior made her uncomfortable. She describes feeling trapped in a difficult position, where rejecting his advances could have professional repercussions.
The Judicial Conduct Tribunal commenced hearings in January 2025 to investigate Mengo’s allegations. During the proceedings, Mbenenge admitted to sending numerous sexually suggestive messages but maintained that the interactions were consensual. He argued that his persistence was a form of cultural courtship and that Mengo had not explicitly rejected his advances.
Mengo has strongly disputed Mbenenge’s version of events, particularly an alleged incident in November 2021, where she claims he exposed himself to her and made explicit propositions. She asserts that Mbenenge’s account of the day in question is false.
Early Life and Background
Hometown and Family
Andiswa Mengo hails from the Eastern Cape, a region known for its rich cultural heritage and history. While specific details about her family are limited, her upbringing in this province has shaped her values and perspectives, influencing her decision to pursue a career in the legal field.
Education
Mengo’s educational journey began in the local schools of the Eastern Cape. From a young age, she demonstrated a keen interest in learning and excelled academically. Her dedication to her studies paved the way for her entry into the legal profession. She attended primary and secondary school in the region, where she was recognized for her academic achievements and leadership qualities. Her commitment to education continued as she pursued further studies, eventually leading to her employment at the Makhanda High Court.
Career in the Judiciary
Role at the Makhanda High Court
Andiswa Mengo serves as a court secretary at the Makhanda High Court, a position that places her at the heart of judicial operations. Her responsibilities include managing court documents, assisting judges with administrative tasks, and ensuring the smooth functioning of court proceedings. Her role is crucial in maintaining the efficiency and integrity of the judicial process.
Professional Reputation
Throughout her career, Mengo has been recognized for her professionalism and dedication to her work. Colleagues describe her as meticulous, reliable, and committed to upholding the standards of the legal profession. Her contributions to the court have been invaluable, and she has earned the respect of her peers for her work ethic and integrity.
Allegations and Complaint
Nature of the Allegations
In January 2023, Andiswa Mengo filed a formal complaint against Judge President Selby Mbenenge, accusing him of sexual harassment. She alleges that between June 2021 and November 2022, Mbenenge engaged in inappropriate in-person and electronic interactions with her, including sending sexually explicit WhatsApp messages and making unwanted advances. Mengo contends that these interactions were unwelcome and that she felt compelled to engage due to the power dynamics at play.
Initial Response and Support
Upon receiving Mengo’s complaint, the Office of the Chief Justice initiated an investigation. However, Mengo later revealed that she had been informed that she was not the first to lodge such a complaint against Mbenenge, suggesting a pattern of behavior.
Testimony and Evidence
Personal Testimony
During the Judicial Conduct Tribunal hearings, Mengo provided detailed testimony about the alleged harassment. She described receiving numerous sexually suggestive messages from Mbenenge, including requests for explicit photographs and comments about her appearance. Mengo testified that she felt uncomfortable and pressured by these interactions but was hesitant to refuse due to Mbenenge’s position of authority.
Digital Evidence
The tribunal examined digital evidence, including WhatsApp messages exchanged between Mengo and Mbenenge. Forensic analysis revealed the presence of sexually explicit emojis and suggestive language in the communications. Experts testified that these messages were consistent with patterns of sexual harassment.
Judicial Conduct Tribunal Proceedings
Overview of the Tribunal
The Judicial Conduct Tribunal was convened to investigate the allegations against Judge President Selby Mbenenge. This marks the first time a sitting judge president is facing such allegations, highlighting the significance of the case.
Mbenenge’s Defense
Throughout the tribunal, Mbenenge has denied the allegations, asserting that the interactions were consensual and flirtatious. He claims that his interest in Mengo was sparked by her mannerisms and that he did not perceive his actions as inappropriate. Mbenenge’s legal team has also challenged the interpretation of the digital evidence, questioning the context and intent behind the messages.
Cultural Context Argument
Mbenenge’s defense has introduced cultural context into the proceedings, arguing that his actions align with Xhosa courting traditions, which may involve persistence in expressing romantic interest. This argument has been met with criticism from gender experts, who contend that cultural practices should not excuse behavior that constitutes harassment.
Personal Life
Family and Relationships
Details about Mengo’s personal life, including her family and relationships, are kept private. She has chosen to focus public attention on the legal proceedings and the broader implications of her case.
Advocacy and Impact
Beyond her role in the tribunal, Mengo has become an advocate for victims of workplace harassment. Her decision to come forward has inspired others to speak out and has brought attention to the need for stronger protections against harassment in the workplace.
Net Worth and Salary
Specific details about Mengo’s net worth and salary are not publicly disclosed. As a court secretary at the Makhanda High Court, her compensation would align with standard public service pay scales in South Africa.
Conclusion
Andiswa Mengo’s decision to come forward with her allegations against Judge President Selby Mbenenge has initiated a crucial conversation about sexual harassment, power dynamics, and accountability within South Africa’s judiciary. As the Judicial Conduct Tribunal continues its proceedings, the outcome of this case could set a significant precedent for how such allegations are handled in the future. Mengo’s courage in speaking out serves as a reminder of the importance of upholding integrity and respect within all professional environments.
FAQs
Who is Andiswa Mengo?
Andiswa Mengo is a court secretary at the Makhanda High Court in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. She has come forward with allegations of sexual harassment against Judge President Selby Mbenenge.
What are the allegations against Judge President Selby Mbenenge?
Mengo alleges that between June 2021 and November 2022, Mbenenge subjected her to persistent sexual advances, including sending explicit messages and requesting photographs.
What is the Judicial Conduct Tribunal?
The Judicial Conduct Tribunal is a body established to investigate allegations of misconduct against judges in South Africa.
What evidence has been presented in the case?
Digital evidence, including WhatsApp messages and forensic analysis, has been presented to support Mengo’s allegations.
How has Mbenenge responded to the allegations?
Mbenenge denies the allegations, asserting that the interactions were consensual and culturally appropriate.
What is the cultural context argument in the defense?
Mbenenge’s defense argues that his actions align with Xhosa courting traditions, which may involve persistence in expressing romantic interest.
What is the current status of the tribunal?
The tribunal is ongoing, with proceedings expected to conclude in July 2025.
